Send to KindleIt flashed past, and I managed to find it again. A tweet about Cinderella. I really can’t remember much about the original tweet, but that it made me smile and I retweeted it. I do however remember the backlash to my retweet by one of my followers.
[start of scene setting] This person seemed cynical and upset by the fact that Cinderella was shown to be a role model to women. That it was shocking to show a woman being saved by a man and not getting off her bahoochie (Scottish word for backside. Not used by tweeter, but added here to stretch your Scottish vocabulary!) and sorting her life out for herself. Truly it felt like a sledge hammer had been taken to a walnut. She also happened to mention something along the lines of Cinderella running away from the party and not finding her own shoe. [end of scene setting]
This has stayed with me for a while. I was bemused at how someone could make so much of what felt to me as inconsequential. Of course, that’s what happens in life. If it’s one of your hot buttons, you’ll get all worked up about something others wouldn’t have batted an eyelid at. I’ve tried really hard to see it from her perspective and as I was wandering around this morning, I gave it some more thought. Nope, still I’m not getting it.
Fairytales are stories, they are metaphors, they are not literal, simply figurative. And even in that context, I think old Cinders was pretty damn smart to sort her life out just as she wanted. She used what she had available to her in her time of need. Did marriage to a Prince mean she had undersold herself, that she was unable to think for herself ever again, or that she was less of a person? I very much doubt you’ll find Catherine, Mrs Prince William feeling that’s the case.
So let’s look at Cinderella. She wanted to go to the ball, she wanted to meet Prince Charming, who wouldn’t? I mean seriously, when all’s said and done everyone wants to love and be loved. The fact that he was a Prince, is simply the circle her family once belonged to. She’d been ousted and wanted to reclaim her place as a rightful contender for his hand in marriage. Where would you choose for your first date, or to find the kind of partner you’d like to meet? The local cafe, a wine bar, a wedding reception, a black tie do, 5* restaurant?
She despairs that she’ll be unable to attend the ball in her latter day equivalent of joggy bottoms and a baggy t-shirt! Man alive, I know that feeling only too well. How many of us have to get appropriate clothing for functions? As she prays and asks for help from a source larger than herself, as we’ve all done every time we’ve said ‘I wish’, it appears. We always get an answer, we are so often not able to see it because it might not turn the way we expected. Cinders was receptive, she allowed herself to receive. It sure wasn’t what she expected, it was a miracle. I’ve had a few miracles in my life, some wouldn’t think so, but I know they were – coincidences, synchronicities, meeting people at just the right time, etc
There are rules she has to obey to allow the magic to work. I know that one too, don’t you? If you don’t have boundaries in place, then things can go wrong. All parents, or at least the ones I know, tell their teenagers to be home by a certain time, or go and pick them up – how is the Fairy Godmother’s rule any different? If you’re out on a date with someone you’ve met online, don’t you have someone to report home to by a certain hour?
She was having fun and the time flew past. When the bell struck midnight, was she afraid of being seen in her tattered clothes, or was she in fact composmentous and respectful enough to make her choice, which was to obey her elder’s wishes for her. Frankly I’d be fleeing to avoid being seen in my joggy bottoms too and the queues for a taxi!
So, she drops a shoe. In the moment she made another choice about what was more important – a glass shoe she was unlikely to wear again to clean the floors, or to get home. When you’re on the spot, in the moment, your gut tells you which is most important. Have you ever left something at a party and been delighted when the host returns it to you the next day, or calls you to say ‘It’s here’ – yeah, me too, and often sighed with a great sense of relief.
And in this instance, the host knows who the shoe belongs to, just not where to find them. A wonderful hunt begins as searches for the person who he knows opened his heart, set his soul on fire and felt at one with. Piffle, romantic nonsense – nah, when a man and a woman know what they have between them, they will cross oceans, climb mountains, overcome hurdles and do whatever it takes. It’s called focus, intention and love.
Sure, life isn’t all pretty dresses, princes, princesses, castles and happy ever after. And yet. What is in your way to allow it to be so? Every man has the ability to be treated as a prince, every woman a princess. Our homes are our castles and happy ever after – that’s simply a mindset.
Do you have what it takes to create miracles to get what you want? Cinderella did. It starts with loving and being yourself, and a willingness to receive what comes to you with open arms and heart. Yes, I do believe in magic, do you?





I get both sides, and I’ve often said we’ve been screwed by Disney’s interpretation of fairytales! This is definitely a post to put in my back pocket and ponder. I can feel my feminist hackles rising, but I love how you share the logic of Cinderella’s actions. Hmm, back later methinks!
Also? Bahoochie = my new favourite word!
Lol … I’m going to deconstruct them all over time! I adore them and their messages. But then I don’t, and never have, had strong feminist hackles!
Love your post Jackie
My prince calls me his princess and I love it
Reading between the lines of the reaction of your twitter follower, I would think it was possible that she is hurting so badly that she has placed a giant wall up, to stop her being hurt again. I have seen it many times in my pastoral work, that often the very thing that the person is so against, is often the very thing that they actually want, but don’t realise it … yet… that past esperiences have broken giant chunks off hope, that is fast disappearing before them that it’s easier to close the door on it all together.
That’s by far a huge part of the problem these days Anita, and exactly why I love doing what I do! The other side of the coin is that there are many women who have been hardened against admitting that having a man around not to look after them, more to look out for them, as being positive and acceptable. It’s part of the throw back from the many years of feminism, gaining equality and ‘fighting’ for their rights. That in and of itself is positive, but as women we do need to find the balance of masculine and feminine energies.
Yes I agree Jackie. I am often seen a bit old fashioned, but I really see a great realtionship as being equal; loving and being there for each other equally. I love caring for my husband, and am greatly blessed that he wants to do the same for me. It is all about balance
I think you have it here when you say she allowed herself to receive. She allowed for the possibility of magic to occur.
I did something a bit like that a few years ago – I figured I needed to be a bit less old boot and a bit more still believing in fairy tales. I made a collage up of images associated with the innocent archetype, and tried to focus on the softer feeling in me than I was used to.
It was part of what I needed to do to allow love to find the way through the door to my heart.
PS I also love the way you’ve written this, so free, so full of energy, it’s fabulous.
PPS it worked by the way x
Really? Is that how you magicked your happy ending, wow! I love fact as much as fiction
Your PS means so much Joanna, thank you. I think that lying on the floor with circles has really started and ended something!
First off, I love your post and its take on Cinders!
Bahoochie is new to me, though I may have to wait to take that up with my Scottish Mum until I reach the plains where she’s (as far as I know) residing, having popped her earthly clogs last year at a rather respectable age of 86, but I digress…
My take is different from your other commentators yet, in the belief that variety is the spice of life, I shall press on and add my bit to be added to the mix
My principle take on Cinders is that she…
undoubtedly dreamed of something better
and could that have meant she…
was open to possibilities…
that brought her Prince Charming into her life?
Of course, we’re not taken beyond that point.
PC could have turned out to be a right royal pain in the you-know-where
The kids may have turned out as nightmare citizens
And, Cinders herself, who knows?
But she saw the opportunity and went for it, didn’t she?
Totally Linda, I think you’re saying the same as others (and me) just in a different way! She was open to possibilities, and to receiving!
I would have gone on further, but then I would have been straying into my imagination and writing a book! I agree we’ve no idea what happened with her PC, nor their children! And either of them may well have wanted a divorce after a period of time!
However, as you say, she saw the opportunity, went for it, and moved forward. Only after we’ve done that bit, can we be in a position to make new decisions! She was one smart cookie
Cinders wasn’t silly, was she? She took advantage of the fact that after seeing her ugly step-sisters, our Prince Charming would have fancied pretty much anything with a pulse. So with Fairy Godmum’s help, a meringue dress and a coach like the one Katy Price used when getting married to Peter André, she knew she would basically wipe the floor with PC.
The only bit I don’t get is the glass slippers. Given that I haven’t danced for 15 years and fall over when in my trainers, the notion of performing an elegant “polonaise” or “mazurka” in glass slippers makes me admire Cinders even more for her unbelievably high pain threshold if nothing else.
Mind you, I’d like to have seen Cinders dance with young Charming in 7-inch Louboutin platforms, which IMHO make glass slippers look like Dr Scholl orthotic devices. Ho hum.
Better stop blethering or my coach will turn back into a pumpkin…meanwhile, thanks for a delightful post, Jackie!
Lol Suze, I find it a challenge to dance, well ok, walk in very high heels too, I usually kick them off under the table! Hope you got back to your coach in time
Jackie, I got so excited when I read this blog’s title, and all the responses to it.
I love fairy tales and as a transpersonal group we have studied fairy tales for 11 years as an ongoing learning process.
Fairy Tales were never meant for children, but were used by the community wise-woman (today’s counsellors). People would come to her with a problem and she would choose a story that would go straight to the unconscious and would help clients to work through his/her own problem. In other words, to help each grow consiousness and awareness.
The Grimm brothers changed many of the early tales to suit children before the age of reason, giving little thought to their power. As tales deal with problem solving you should never read more than one tale at a time to a child!!! It’s confusing for them.
Then along comes Disney who romantisices them.
Cinderella is said to be published in 1697 and in keeping with all tales deals with archetypes and motives that allow one to deal with a deeper meaning.
The task is not to focus on the physical aspect…. but instead on the spiritual aspects.
What attributes aren’t you recognising? What rescues you?
Cinderells chose the Prince in the story……. the wise-woman would know what Cinderells (client) needed to bring forward was the masculine within herself……which she did do…..by choosing the prince!!!!
Anyone interested in fairy tale meanings might want to read ‘Interpretation of Fairy Tales’ by Marie-Luise von Franz, a Jungian analyst.
look forward to the next great blogging insight.
Hi Jo, I just love story telling, it was the part of my training which I enjoyed most! Even with Disney or Pixar’s interpretations, I always find at least two other levels on the go simultanteously! Maybe that’s why I’m always in tears in the cinema! I’ll look out for the book you recommend, thank you for highlighting it and your group sounds fascinating.
Isn’t that just the truth of it. We are multi-layered and working on both the outer and the inner, and the trick is to seperate one from another; or do we? Hmmm!
We(group) are always fascinated how we can see the truth of the archetypes and yet they play out differently for each of us within our own stories, depending on the issues we are working with at the time (known and unknown)and if the same story is read at a different time…..it’ll be all different again……exciting huh?
Jackie, this is a MAGICAL post! There are so many ‘quotable quotes’ and thought-provoking questions in this piece, I really think you should consider writing a series about it, or an eBook, to explore those ideas in more detail.
I love how you encourage me (and your readers) to take another look at Cinderella and her situation, rather than simply dismiss this fairy tale as outdated, yet another fanciful story of how a helpless female was rescued by a man.
When you ask, ‘Do you have what it takes to create miracles to get what you want?’ I literally stopped reading further to think about it. I think I’ll have to spend some time really thinking this one through, since it’s a very profound question. Could it be true that we could experience miracles and happy ever-afters in our lives ‘just’ by being completely open to receiving them? It’s this ‘just’ state that I’m going to be thinking about…
How I smiled reading your ‘just’ state Carole! It’s where everything happens, the suspension of belief and disbelief. You already are living and experiencing miracles, look around you, it’s your turn to now smile
I never saw these aspects of the Cinderella story before! But I’m with Jo, who loves and appreciates fairy tales. They have something to tell us about our psyche, and their messages aren’t always easy to swallow.
Isn’t that the truth Mary, it’s much easier to turn away, scoff and ignore the stirrings. I love to create curiosity with the aim of encouraging new perspectives and questions instead of blind acceptance.
Lovely read Jackie, even I feel charmed by Cinderella after reading this
Gracious Sarah, that”s praise indeed
I understand the objection to the idea that all a woman really needs for her life to be perfect is a man. However, when I was of that age, finding the right guy was all I really wanted. Even now, I’d feel there was something missing without a partner, not because I’m not okay on my own but because joy shared is multiplied, right?
Great conversation about the deeper meaning of fairy tales. I just taught a fairy tale unit with second graders, and this conversation and perhaps the book Jo recommended will certainly inform that class the next time I teach it.
Wonderful and unique interpretation that allows me to see this story from another side. Brilliant. And I agree with everyone who has said that Disney ruins fairy tales–it upsets me so that whole generations of kids thing that the Disney version (cute mice!) of Cinderella is the real deal. I always read my kids the real stories.
Thanks Charlotte! I love the Disney films, and I fully appreciate that they gild the lily and therefore plant expectations without a healthy dose of reality.
[...] week I wrote about how Cinderella is a great role model. What I forgot to mention was that she’d been a client of mine, obviously it was only in [...]
Jackie – if the person who objected was of my generation, it’s more than likely she’d read ‘The Cinderella Complex’ by Colette Dowling: http://www.amazon.co.uk/The-Cinderella-Complex-Womens-Independence/dp/0671733346
Thanks Judy, that’s quite possible … I know a lot of people go into the negative messages in Disney and fairy tales, I wanted to show something positive.